Key West is far more famous for painted, mostly nude bodies than it is for dead ones. Although there have been several cases of multiple murders over the years, there has never been a trail of bodies stretching across the country, ending in Key West. Tess and Tuesday have finally accepted that they are a gay couple. After almost a year in Key West, it's time to visit Diane Isis Bar & Girl and try to blend into the local lesbian community. Nathan has grown used to spending time with the girls most evenings, as well as their days off. Their change in routine, resulting in his seeing much less of them, coupled with his own serious relationship issues, leaves him at loose ends and far too much free time on his hands. Key West hasn't had a serious hurricane since 2005. New arrivals often struggle with deciding whether to stay and hunker down through storms, or evacuate. This year starts off fairly normal, but that ends far too soon, causing Tess, Nathan, and Tuesday to continue having to make the choice of should they stay or should they go. This year, the wrong choice could be a real killer.