Novah initially agreed to participate in a polyamorous relationship with Genie, her best friend and their shared boyfriend, Keith Steele, the love of Novah's life whom she's pined for since they went their separate ways after high school. She finally has her man and is living the life she's always dreamed of, but when a misrouted delivery results in her meeting Scott, a sexy and successful Irish man, Novah finds herself unexpectedly falling for him and is swept up in a tornado of confusion.
As her connection with Scott grows stronger, things seem to be going downhill for Novah's throuple relationship, and against her better judgement, Novah informs her lovers that she's taken on a new lover, which soon threatens to derail the happy home she struggled so hard to create. Meanwhile, the relationship between Keith and Genie seems to be growing more profound each day, causing Novah to second guess her heart. Secrets being exposed and feelings becoming unconfined leads to betrayal and jealousy. The unexpected and dramatic turns in this emotionally charged sequel promise a dynamic roller coaster ride of a polyamorous relationship and what it really takes to make it all work.